FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · CHAPTER 3

2D Crystallography III

Four Crystal Systems, Five Bravais Lattices & 17 Plane Groups
TEXTBOOK § 3.7 – § 3.8 · LATTICES, GLIDE LINES & PLANE GROUPS
“From geometric patterns on woven textiles down to atomic arrangements in graphene and transition-metal dichalcogenides, every periodic pattern on a 2D plane belongs to one of these 17 plane groups.”Fundamentals of Materials Science · Ch. 3 Epilogue · In Tribute to Fedorov (1891) & Pólya (1924)
Liang Wumse3d.com · Smart Classroom
Glide-coupled network of plane group p2gg: zero pure mirrors, yet orthogonal glide lines induce 2-fold axes
ClickWheel→ NextP PenL LaserO OverviewF FullB Blank
OPENING

Two Opening Questions

QUESTION 1

2D point groups clearly allow 3-fold axes (3, 3m)—why are there only 4 crystal systems (oblique, rectangular, square, hexagonal) with no separate “trigonal system”, and why does centering add just 1 new Bravais lattice?

C₃ + (−T) ⇒ Hexagon C₆ Oblique + c → p oblique Rect. + c → c-rect. (unique!) Square + c → p square (45°) Hex. + c → p rectangular
QUESTION 2

With zero pure mirror lines, how can “flip + half-period shift” spontaneously generate 2-fold rotation axes? And why do graphene and monolayer h-BN—both honeycomb nets—have different plane groups?

Graphene (all C): p6mm Monolayer h-BN: p3m1
Coupling lattice translations with local point groups builds the complete 2D architecture: 4 crystal systems · 5 Bravais lattices · 10 point groups · 17 plane groups.
2D Crystallography III
ROADMAP

From Bare Lattice Classification to the 17 Plane Groups

  1. Unit & W–S CellsPrimitive vs. conv. cell
    Bisector proximity domain
    Interactive
  2. Rot.–Trans. Coupling1→2 & 3→6 upgrades
    Four 2D crystal systems
    Model × 2
  3. Cell CenteringClosure \(2\boldsymbol{T}_{\mathrm{new}}\in\Lambda\)
    Five 2D Bravais lattices
    Model
  4. Glide & AbsencesNon-symmorphic \(g = m \oplus \boldsymbol{T}/2\)
    p2gg induces 2-fold axes
    Model · Interactive
  5. 17 Plane GroupsH–M symbol flowchart
    Sweater · Chess · h-BN
    Model · Synthesis
Covers Textbook § 3.7 – § 3.8 and Chapter 3 Synthesis with six embedded models, building every conceptual bridge to the 230 3D space groups in Chapter 4.
2D Crystallography III
01
PART ONE

2D Crystal Systems & Five Bravais Lattices

Distinguish primitive, conventional, and Wigner–Seitz cells first, then deduce the five distinct 2D Bravais lattices via lattice inversion and centering closure.
  1. Primitive, Conventional & Wigner–Seitz Cells05
  2. Rotation–Translation Coupling: 1→2 & 3→606
  3. Four 2D Crystal Systems & Metric Constraints07
  4. Algebraic Closure of Unit-Cell Centering08
  5. Deduction of the Five 2D Bravais Lattices09
§ 3.7.1 · THREE FACES OF THE UNIT CELL

Primitive Minimizes Area, Conventional Shows Mirrors, W–S Achieves Both

  • Primitive cell: Smallest-area repeating unit containing strictly 1 equivalent lattice point, with area \(S = |\det(\boldsymbol{a}, \boldsymbol{b})|\).
  • Conventional cell: Higher-symmetry parallelogram chosen to display orthogonal mirrors and rotation axes clearly (e.g., centered rectangle containing 2 lattice points).
  • Wigner–Seitz (W–S) cell: Proximity domain bounded by perpendicular bisectors to neighboring lattice points—contains 1 point while preserving full point-group symmetry (in reciprocal space, the 1st Brillouin zone!).
Textbook § 3.7.1 · Unit, Primitive & Wigner–Seitz Cells (Fig. 3.18)
§ 3.7.2 · INHERENT LATTICE INVERSION

Paired \(\boldsymbol{T}\) and \(-\boldsymbol{T}\) Enforce \(C_2\): No Separate 2D Trigonal System

\(\begin{gathered}\boldsymbol{T}\in\Lambda \;\Longleftrightarrow\; -\boldsymbol{T}\in\Lambda\\\Longrightarrow\;(x,y)\to(-x,-y)\equiv C_2\end{gathered}\)
  • 1-fold upgrades to 2-fold: Stripped of any motif, every 2D lattice coincides with itself under \(180^\circ\) rotation about any lattice point (and displaced midpoints \(\boldsymbol{T}/2\)), so its holohedry contains at least \(C_2\).
  • 3-fold upgrades to 6-fold: Composing \(C_3\) with \(C_2\) at a lattice point gives \(120^\circ + 180^\circ = 300^\circ \equiv -60^\circ\) (\(C_6\)); three \(120^\circ\) neighbors paired with \(-\boldsymbol{T}\) form a regular hexagon!
  • Verdict: Every 2D lattice with a 3-fold axis is a hexagonal lattice—trigonal is not a separate 2D crystal system.
Textbook § 3.7.2 · Coupling of Rotation and Translation in Bravais Lattices (Fig. 3.19)
§ 3.7.2 · FOUR 2D CRYSTAL SYSTEMS

Characteristic 2-, 4-, and 6-Fold Axes with Mirrors Define Four Crystal Systems

2D Crystal SystemHolohedryBasis Constraints
Oblique\(\mathrm{2}\ (C_2)\)\(a \ne b,\ \theta \ne 90^\circ\)
Rectangular\(\mathrm{2mm}\ (D_2)\)\(a \ne b,\ \theta = 90^\circ\)
Square\(\mathrm{4mm}\ (D_4)\)\(a = b,\ \theta = 90^\circ\)
Hexagonal\(\mathrm{6mm}\ (D_6)\)\(a = b,\ \theta = 120^\circ\)

Key rule: A crystal system is defined by the intrinsic highest point symmetry (holohedry) of the lattice, not by an arbitrarily skewed basis—switch to the W–S cell to spot true symmetry immediately.

Textbook § 3.7.2 · Four 2D Crystal Systems, Unit Cells & Metric Constraints (Fig. 3.20)
§ 3.7.3 · WHY ONLY AT THE CELL CENTER?

Translational Closure Requires \(2\boldsymbol{T}_{\mathrm{new}}\in\Lambda\): Off-Center Points Break Equivalence

\(2\boldsymbol{T}_{\mathrm{new}} = 2x\boldsymbol{a} + 2y\boldsymbol{b} = u\boldsymbol{a} + v\boldsymbol{b} \quad (u, v \in \mathbb{Z})\)
  • Identical-environment rule: Any added point \(P(x, y)\) must share the exact same translation environment as corners; doubling density requires two hops \(2\boldsymbol{T}_{\mathrm{new}}\) to land on an original node, forcing \(2x, 2y\in\mathbb{Z}\).
  • Four candidates → one survivor: \((0,0)\) is the corner; edge midpoints \((1/2,0)\) and \((0,1/2)\) merely halve a basis vector (still primitive); only cell centering \((1/2, 1/2)\) can yield a new lattice!
  • Off-center counterexample: At \(x\approx 0.618\), a second hop \(\boldsymbol{T}_2\) spawns extra points with unequal spacings \(\boldsymbol{T}_3\ne\boldsymbol{T}_4\), destroying discrete lattice equivalence.
(b) Exact midpoint T₁ = T/2: every hop closes on Λ ✓ (c–d) Off-center T₂ = 0.618T: 2nd hop misses node (T₃ ≠ T₄) ✗ T₃ = 0.382T T₄ = 0.236T (inequivalent!)
Textbook § 3.7.3 · Closure Constraint on 1D & 2D Lattice Centering Positions (Fig. 3.21)
§ 3.7.3 · CENTERING TEST ACROSS FOUR SYSTEMS

Only Rectangular Centering Resists Reduction: 4 Systems Yield 5 Bravais Lattices

  • Oblique + centering: Connecting \((1/2,1/2)\) to corners gives a half-area skewed cell ⇒ still primitive oblique (p).
  • Rectangular + centering: Its minimal primitive cell is a non-orthogonal rhombus (\(\theta'\ne 90^\circ\)) that obscures the 2mm mirrors, so the 2-point orthogonal cell is kept ⇒ centered rectangular (c, unique new lattice! Gives cm, c2mm).
  • Square + centering: Rotating axes by \(45^\circ\) with \(a'=a/\sqrt{2}\) gives a smaller square ⇒ still primitive square (p).
  • Hexagonal + centering: Unequal neighbor distances break 6-fold symmetry ⇒ degrades to primitive rectangular (p).
Textbook § 3.7.3 · Unit-Cell Centering & Five 2D Bravais Lattices (Figs. 3.22–3.23)
02
PART TWO

Glide Lines & the 17 Plane Groups

Nesting the 10 crystallographic point groups into the 5 Bravais lattices—plus non-symmorphic glide reflections—exhausts every periodic pattern in 2D.
  1. Symmorphic vs. Non-Symmorphic & Glide Line \(g\)11
  2. Four-Step Generation of Non-Symmorphic p2gg12
  3. Symmetry Compatibility & Atlas of 17 Plane Groups13
  4. H–M Symbol Code & Identification Flowchart14
  5. Pattern Identification: Sweater, Chessboard & h-BN15
  6. Chapter 3 Synthesis & Stepping Up to 3D16
§ 3.8.1 · THE UNIQUE 2D NON-SYMMORPHIC OPERATION

Glide Reflection \(g\): Mirror Plus Half-Period Shift \(\tau = \boldsymbol{T}/2\) Causes Absences

\(g = m \oplus \frac{\boldsymbol{T}}{2}, \qquad g^2 = \boldsymbol{T} \in \Lambda\)
  • Symmorphic plane groups (13): Rotations and mirrors decouple from fractional translations and intersect at a common lattice origin without conflict.
  • Non-symmorphic plane groups (4: pg, p2mg, p2gg, p4gm): Contain intrinsic glide lines \(g\) (dashed)—reflect across the line (reversing chirality, pale intermediate) then shift by \(\boldsymbol{T}/2\); repeating twice closes into \(g^2=\boldsymbol{T}\).
  • Physical consequences: Half-period fractional shifts cause destructive half-wave interference (systematic absences in X-ray diffraction) and enforce Brillouin-zone-boundary band degeneracies.
Textbook § 3.8.1 · Symmorphic vs. Non-Symmorphic Groups, Glide Reflection & Systematic Absences (Fig. 3.24)
§ 3.8.2 · PLANE-GROUP GENERATION PARADIGM

p2gg: Zero Pure Mirrors, Yet Two Orthogonal Glide Lines Induce 2-Fold Axes

\(g_x \circ g_y = 2 \quad (\text{double glide} \equiv 180^\circ \text{ rotation})\)
  • (a) Initial motif 1: Place an asymmetric red F inside a primitive rectangular cell (currently p1).
  • (b) Horizontal glide \(g_x\): Flip across the horizontal dashed line (pale teal intermediate), then shift \(+a/2\) to lock in teal motif 2.
  • (c) Vertical glide \(g_y\): Motif 1 generates teal 3; teal motif 2 flips again (two reflections restore red chirality!) and shifts \(+b/2\) to form red motif 4.
  • (d) Induced 2-fold axes: Red 1 and red 4 coincide under a \(180^\circ\) turn about the cell center—every induced 2-fold axis lies off the glide lines!
Textbook § 3.8.2 · Four-Step Geometric & Algebraic Generation of Plane Group p2gg (Fig. 3.25)
§ 3.8.2 · FEDOROV (1891) & PÓLYA (1924)

Symmetry Compatibility Governs Pairing: Periodic 2D Patterns Converge to 17 Groups

2D Crystal System (Bravais Lattice)Compatible Point GroupsInternational (H–M) Plane-Group Symbols (17 Total)
Oblique (primitive p)1, 2p1, p2 (2 groups)
Rectangular (primitive p / centered c)m, 2mmpm, pg, cm; p2mm, p2mg, p2gg, c2mm (7 groups)
Square (primitive p)4, 4mmp4; p4mm, p4gm (3 groups)
Hexagonal (primitive p)3, 3m, 6, 6mmp3; p3m1, p31m; p6; p6mm (5 groups)
Compatibility rule: Lattice holohedry must contain the motif point group (placing a 4mm square motif onto an oblique lattice immediately lowers overall symmetry). Among the 17 groups, the 4 containing g are non-symmorphic and the other 13 are symmorphic.
Textbook § 3.8.2 · Compatibility Table of 2D Crystal Systems, Point Groups & 17 Plane Groups (Table 3.7, Fig. 3.26)
§ 3.8.3 · FOUR CHARACTERS ENCODE ALL SYMMETRY ELEMENTS

H–M Symbol Code & Flowchart: Centering, Principal Axis, and Mirror Orientations

p2gg / p2mg

p: Primitive rectangular lattice
2: 2-fold principal rotation axis
gg: Glide lines along both orthogonal axes \(x, y\) (0 pure mirrors)
mg: Pure mirror m along one axis, glide g along the other

p4gm

p: Primitive square lattice
4: Principal 4-fold rotation axis (\(90^\circ\))
g (primary): Glide lines parallel to crystal axes \(x, y\)
m (secondary): Pure mirrors along \(45^\circ\) diagonals

p6mm · p3m1 vs. p31m

p6mm: Hexagonal p + 6-fold + mirrors \(\perp\) basis + mirrors \(\parallel\) basis (\(30^\circ\) apart)
p3m1: Retains mirrors \(\perp\) basis (short diagonal, through all 3-folds)
p31m: Retains mirrors \(\parallel\) basis (long diagonal, rotated \(30^\circ\))

Systematic Identification Flowchart: ① Minimal cell & holohedry → system & p/c → ② Highest n-fold axis (1/2/3/4/6) → point group → ③ Half-period reflection test → m vs. g & basis orientation.
Textbook § 3.8.3 · Hermann–Mauguin Symbol Decoding & Identification Flowchart
§ 3.8.3 · WORKED IDENTIFICATION CASES

From Knitted Sweaters to Graphene and Monolayer h-BN: Three-Step Identification

  • Sweater pattern (Ex. 3.4) → p2mm: Rectangular cell \(a\ne b,\ \theta=90^\circ\) (primitive p) + motif with 2-fold axis and orthogonal pure mirrors (2mm), zero glide lines.
  • Chessboard → p4mm: Dark and light tiles are inequivalent; same-color centers form a \(45^\circ\) diagonal square lattice p with 4-fold axes and 4 mirror sets at tile centers.
  • Graphene p6mm vs. monolayer \(\mathrm{h\text{-}BN}\) p3m1: All-carbon rings have 6-fold symmetry; alternating B and N vertices map B → N under \(60^\circ\) (chemically inequivalent!), breaking \(C_6\) down to \(C_3\) and removing one mirror family!
Textbook § 3.8.3 · Three-Step Plane-Group Identification in Practice (Fig. 3.27)
CHAPTER 3 SYNTHESIS · STEPPING UP TO 3D

Master the Group-Theory Skeleton in 2D, and 3D Space Groups Unfold Naturally

  • Lattice skeleton: Characteristic rotation axes + lattice inversion ⇒ 4 crystal systems; centering closure \(2\boldsymbol{T}_{\mathrm{new}}\in\Lambda\) ⇒ 5 Bravais lattices.
  • Local point groups: Crystallographic restriction (\(\cos\alpha=m/2\), \(\varphi(n)\le 2\)) ⇒ 10 crystallographic 2D point groups.
  • Global coupling: Point groups × translations + non-symmorphic glide lines \(g\) ⇒ 17 plane groups.
  • Chapter 4 in 3D: Mirror lines become planes, glide lines become glide planes, plus 3D inversion \(\bar{1}\) and screw axes ⇒ 7 systems · 14 lattices · 32 point groups · 230 space groups!
Textbook Chapter 3 Epilogue · From 2D Plane Groups to 3D Space Groups (Fig. 3.28)
CHAPTER 3 SUMMARY

From Abstract Lattice Points to 17 Plane Groups: Complete 2D Symmetry Synthesis

W–S Cell & T/−T Inversion→4 Crystal Systems→Centering → 5 Lattices→10 Point Groups + Glide g→17 Plane Groups
ANSWER TO QUESTION 1

Every 2D Bravais lattice carries \(\boldsymbol{T}/-\boldsymbol{T}\) inversion (\(\equiv C_2\)), so \(C_3\circ C_2 = C_6\) merges trigonal into the hexagonal lattice; among the 4 systems, only centered rectangular has a non-orthogonal rhombic primitive cell, adding just 1 centered lattice (c).

ANSWER TO QUESTION 2

In p2gg, two orthogonal glide reflections apply two mirror flips that cancel chirality reversal and compose into a \(180^\circ\) pure rotation (\(g_x\circ g_y=2\)); in monolayer h-BN, alternating B and N atoms break \(60^\circ\) equivalence, lowering graphene’s p6mm to p3m1.

Next up: Chapter 4 (3D Crystallography) — stepping into real bulk materials with 7 crystal systems, 14 Bravais lattices, close packing, and prototype inorganic structures.

2D Crystallography III · End of Chapter 3
QUICK QUIZ

Three Concept Checks: Click an Option or Launch a Class QR Poll

1. Why is there no independent “centered square” Bravais lattice in 2D crystallography?

Adding a center point to a square forms a smaller square primitive cell of side \(a/\sqrt{2}\) rotated by \(45^\circ\) (\(\theta'=90^\circ\)), isomorphic to primitive square.

2. Out of the 17 2D plane groups, how many are non-symmorphic (containing intrinsic glide lines g)?

2D has 13 symmorphic and 4 non-symmorphic plane groups: pg, p2mg, p2gg, and p4gm (in hexagonal groups, glides always coexist with parallel mirrors m).

3. What are the 2D plane groups of pristine monolayer graphene and monolayer hexagonal BN (h-BN)?

All-carbon graphene has 6-fold ring centers and two mirror sets (p6mm); alternating B/N in h-BN breaks 6-fold to 3-fold and removes one mirror set (p3m1).

2D Crystallography III
FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · END OF CHAPTER 3

Thank You

6 Embedded Models: Choosing a Unit Cell · Rotation–Translation Coupling · 2D Crystal Systems · 2D Bravais Lattices · 2D Glide Reflections · 17 Plane Groups — mse3d.com