FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · CHAPTER 4

3D Crystallography II

Crystallographic Directions, Miller–Bravais Indices, Planes & Zone Law
TEXTBOOK § 4.4 – § 4.5 · QUANTITATIVE 3D CRYSTALLOGRAPHIC GEOMETRY
“The Miller indices of a crystal plane are simultaneously the coordinates of its reciprocal-lattice vector—a dual identity uniting real-space slip and cleavage with reciprocal-space diffraction spots.”Fundamentals of Materials Science · Ch. 4 · In Tribute to W. H. Miller (1839) & P. P. Ewald (1913)
Liang Wumse3d.com · Smart Classroom
Close-packed (111) plane, [111] surface normal, and three co-zonal ⟨110⟩ slip directions in a cubic cell
ClickWheel→ NextP PenL LaserO OverviewF FullB Blank
OPENING

Two Opening Questions

QUESTION 01 · WHY FOUR INDICES IN 3D SPACE?

A hexagonal unit cell sits in 3D space where three basis vectors \(\boldsymbol{a}_1,\boldsymbol{a}_2,\boldsymbol{c}\) are already linearly independent. Why add a redundant basal axis \(\boldsymbol{a}_3\) and use four-index notation \([uvtw]\) and \((hkil)\) for Mg, Ti, and GaN?

QUESTION 02 · IS [hkl] ALWAYS PERPENDICULAR TO (hkl)?

In a cubic crystal, the body diagonal \([111]\) is strictly perpendicular to the octahedral plane \((111)\). If that cell is stretched along \(c\) into a tetragonal cell with \(c=1.5a\), is \([111]\) still perpendicular to \((111)\)?

Core Mission of This Lecture

Once basis axes are chosen, we need a universal quantitative language for directions and planes across all seven crystal systems—indexing single-crystal turbine-blade growth axes and wafer cuts while computing slip-plane angles, XRD spacings \(d_{hkl}\), and TEM zone axes.

Bracket Discipline: Atomic site \((q,r,s)\) · Specific direction \([uvw]\) · Equivalent direction family \(\langle uvw\rangle\) · Specific plane \((hkl)\) · Equivalent plane family \(\{hkl\}\). Never mix the five bracket types!
Textbook § 4.4 – § 4.5 · Crystallographic Indexing & Zone Geometry
LECTURE ROADMAP

From a Single Direction Vector to Universal Zone Geometry in Five Steps

  1. Sites & DirectionsFractional coords \((q,r,s)\) & coprime integers \([uvw]\)§ 4.4.1–4.4.2
  2. Miller–Bravais 4-Index\(120^\circ\) basal symmetry & cyclic \([uvtw]\) permutation§ 4.4.2
  3. Miller PlanesShift origin, read intercepts & reciprocals \((hkl)/(hkil)\)§ 4.4.3
  4. Angles & SpacingCanonical cubic angles, \(d_{hkl}\) & metric tensor \(\boldsymbol{g}\)§ 4.5.1–4.5.2
  5. Weiss Zone LawUniversal co-zonal test \(hu+kv+lw=0\) & cross products§ 4.5.3
Chapter 4 · Part 2 (§ 4.4 – § 4.5)
01
PART ONE

Atomic Coordinates, Direction Indices & 4-Index System

Measure lattice sites and vectors in basis units, then restore 6-fold cyclic symmetry in hexagonal crystals with four indices.
  1. Fractional coordinates \((q,r,s)\) & direction indices \([uvw]\)5
  2. Equivalent direction families \(\langle uvw\rangle\) & symmetry breaking6
  3. Hexagonal Miller–Bravais direction indices \([uvtw]\)7
§ 4.4.1 – § 4.4.2 · ATOMIC COORDINATES & DIRECTION VECTORS

Head Minus Tail, Coprime Integers, Overbars: Four Steps to Index \([uvw]\)

\(\begin{gathered}\Delta\boldsymbol{r}=(q_2-q_1)\boldsymbol{a}+(r_2-r_1)\boldsymbol{b}+(s_2-s_1)\boldsymbol{c}\\m(q_2-q_1,\,r_2-r_1,\,s_2-s_1)=(u,v,w)\Rightarrow[uvw]\end{gathered}\)
  • Fractional coordinates \((q,r,s)\): Measured in units of basis lengths \(a,b,c\) (regardless of axis orthogonality!); integer shifts represent translationally equivalent sites.
  • Worked Case 4.2: From tail \(A(1,0,1)\) to head \(B(0,1,\tfrac{1}{2})\), subtract \((-1,1,-\tfrac{1}{2})\) and multiply by \(2\) to clear fractions: \((-2,2,-1)\Rightarrow\) \([\bar{2}2\bar{1}]\).
  • Sense reversal: Reversing a vector negates every index—the opposite of \([\bar{2}2\bar{1}]\) is \([2\bar{2}1]\) (collinear, opposite sense).
Textbook § 4.4.1–4.4.2 · Atomic Coordinates & Direction Indexing (Cases 4.1–4.2)
§ 4.4.2 · EQUIVALENT DIRECTION FAMILIES ⟨uvw⟩

Point-Group Operations Unite \(\langle uvw\rangle\) Families; Lower Symmetry Splits Them

\(\boldsymbol{R}_z(90^\circ)\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\\0\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}0&-1&0\\1&0&0\\0&0&1\end{pmatrix}\begin{pmatrix}1\\0\\0\end{pmatrix}=\begin{pmatrix}0\\1\\0\end{pmatrix}\)
  • Core cubic families: Point group \(\mathrm{m\bar{3}m}\) permits all permutations and sign flips of \(u,v,w\)—edges \(\langle 100\rangle\) (6), face diagonals \(\langle 110\rangle\) (12), body diagonals \(\langle 111\rangle\) (8), general \(\langle uvw\rangle\) up to 48.
  • Engineering anisotropy: In bcc \(\alpha\text{-Fe}\), atoms pack tightest along \(\langle 111\rangle\) while magnetization is easiest along \(\langle 100\rangle\) (Goss-textured Si steel); fcc Cu and Al are close-packed along \(\langle 110\rangle\).
  • Tetragonal splitting: Stretching to \(a=b\neq c\) removes diagonal 3-fold axes, forbidding \(w\) swaps—cubic’s six \(\langle 100\rangle\) split into basal \(\langle 100\rangle\) (4) and axial \(\langle 001\rangle\) (2)!
System & Point GroupPermutation RuleRepresentative Families
Cubic \(\mathrm{m\bar{3}m}\)
\(a=b=c\)
All \(u,v,w\) permutations + all signs\(\langle 100\rangle\): 6 · \(\langle 110\rangle\): 12
\(\langle 111\rangle\): 8 · \(\langle 123\rangle\): 48
Tetragonal \(\mathrm{4/mmm}\)
\(a=b\neq c\)
Swap/negate \(u,v\) only; negate \(w\)\(\langle 100\rangle\): 4 (\(\pm[100],\pm[010]\))
\(\langle 001\rangle\): 2 (\(\pm[001]\), distinct!)
Orthorhombic \(\mathrm{mmm}\)
\(a\neq b\neq c\)
No swaps; independent sign flips\(\langle 100\rangle\): 2 · \(\langle 010\rangle\): 2 · \(\langle 001\rangle\): 2
\(\langle 111\rangle\): 8
Core Criterion: Two directions belong to the same \(\langle uvw\rangle\) family not because their digits look alike, but iff a point-group matrix of the crystal maps one onto the other!
Textbook § 4.4.2 · Matrix Derivation & Splitting of Direction Families \(\langle uvw\rangle\)
§ 4.4.2 · HEXAGONAL MILLER–BRAVAIS DIRECTIONS [uvtw]

Adding \(\boldsymbol{a}_3=-(\boldsymbol{a}_1+\boldsymbol{a}_2)\) Fixes \(u+v+t=0\), Restoring Cyclic Symmetry

\(\begin{gathered}u=\tfrac{1}{3}(2U-V),\quad v=\tfrac{1}{3}(2V-U)\\t=-(u+v),\quad w=W\\U=2u+v,\;\;V=u+2v,\;\;W=w\end{gathered}\)
  • 3-index blind spot: Three \(120^\circ\)-equivalent close-packed basal axes read \([100],[110],[010]\) in 3-index form—hiding their equivalence—whereas 4-index notation reveals cyclic \([2\bar{1}\bar{1}0],\,[11\bar{2}0],\,[\bar{1}2\bar{1}0]\)!
  • Worked Case 4.4: For \(A(1,1,0)\to B(0,-1,\tfrac{1}{2})\), 3-index shift \((-1,-2,\tfrac{1}{2})\) converts to \((0,-1,1,\tfrac{1}{2})\), clearing fractions (\(\times 2\)) to \([0\bar{2}21]\) (check \(0-2+2=0\)).
Textbook § 4.4.2 · Hexagonal Miller–Bravais Directions (Eqs. 4.8–4.9, Case 4.4)
02
PART TWO

Miller Plane Indices \((hkl)\) & Hexagonal \((hkil)\)

Reciprocal intercepts tame parallel-axis infinities and condense an entire stack of parallel atomic planes into coprime integers.
  1. Three-step indexing of Miller planes \((hkl)\)9
  2. Core cubic plane families & hexagonal planes \((hkil)\)10
§ 4.4.3 · MILLER PLANE INDICES (hkl)

Avoid Origin, Read Intercepts, Clear Reciprocals: Three Steps to \((hkl)\)

\(\left(\frac{1}{p}:\frac{1}{q}:\frac{1}{r}\right)\;\xrightarrow{\text{coprime integers}}\;(hkl)\)
  • Rule 1 (Shift if through \(O\)): If a plane passes through origin \(O\), intercepts vanish and reciprocals diverge! Shift \(O\) to an adjacent lattice point (or pick the next parallel plane): in Case 4.3, shifting \(O\to A(1,0,0)\) yields \((-\infty,-1,1)\Rightarrow(0\bar{1}1)\).
  • Rule 2 (Coprime vs. diffraction order): Geometric Miller indices \((hkl)\) must be coprime; Ch. 5 Laue indices \((nh\,nk\,nl)\) (such as \((200)\)) retain factor \(n\) for \(n\)-th order diffraction or \(d/n\) sub-spacing.
Textbook § 4.4.3 · Three-Step Plane Indexing (Case 4.3, Fig. 4.22)
§ 4.4.3 · {hkl} PLANE FAMILIES & HEXAGONAL (hkil)

Core Cubic Families Shape Polyhedra; Hexagonal Planes Obey \(i=-(h+k)\)

\(\begin{gathered}\boldsymbol{a}_1+\boldsymbol{a}_2+\boldsymbol{a}_3=\boldsymbol{0}\\\Longrightarrow\;h+k+i=0,\;\;i=-(h+k)\end{gathered}\)
  • Core cubic families: \(\{100\}\) cube faces (3 parallel sets / 6 faces), \(\{110\}\) rhombic dodecahedron (6 sets / 12 faces, primary bcc slip), \(\{111\}\) octahedron (4 sets / 8 faces, primary fcc slip & diamond cleavage).
  • Direct hexagonal \((hkil)\) rule (do not mix with \([uvtw]\)!): No \(1/3\) factor! Directly insert \(i=-(h+k)\) into 3-axis \((hkl)\)—Case 4.5 intercepts \((1,\infty,1)\) give pyramidal \((10\bar{1}1)\), and 6 prism faces unite as \(\{10\bar{1}0\}\).
Textbook § 4.4.3 · Cubic \(\{hkl\}\) & Hexagonal \((hkil)\) Planes (Case 4.5)
03
PART THREE

Interplanar Angles, Spacing & Weiss Zone Law

Unify interplanar spacings \(d_{hkl}\) via the metric tensor, then lock co-zonal planes and directions with one lattice-parameter-free law.
  1. Cubic normality & three canonical angles12
  2. Interplanar spacing \(d_{hkl}\) & metric tensor \(\boldsymbol{g}\)13
  3. Weiss zone law \(hu+kv+lw=0\) & cross-product intersections14
§ 4.5.1 · NORMALITY THEOREM & INTERPLANAR ANGLES

Cubic Symmetry Alone Guarantees \([hkl]\perp(hkl)\), Yielding Three Canonical Angles

\(\cos\theta=\frac{h_1h_2+k_1k_2+l_1l_2}{\sqrt{h_1^2+k_1^2+l_1^2}\sqrt{h_2^2+k_2^2+l_2^2}}\quad(\text{cubic only!})\)
  • Cubic privilege & non-cubic warning: Only in cubic crystals (\(\boldsymbol{g}=a^2\boldsymbol{I}\)) does \([hkl]\perp(hkl)\) hold universally; stretching to tetragonal (\(c\neq a\)) tilts \([111]\parallel(a,a,c)\) away from plane normal \(\boldsymbol{n}\propto(1/a,1/a,1/c)\)!
  • \(54.74^\circ\): \((111)\wedge(100)=\arccos(1/\sqrt{3})\)—self-limiting KOH wet-etched V-groove sidewall angle on \((100)\) Si wafers.
  • \(70.53^\circ\) & \(109.47^\circ\): Adjacent slip planes \((111)\wedge(\bar{1}11)=\arccos(1/3)\approx 70.53^\circ\); its supplement is the tetrahedral \(\mathrm{sp^3}\) bond angle \([111]\wedge[1\bar{1}\bar{1}]=\arccos(-1/3)\approx 109.47^\circ\).
Textbook § 4.5.1 · Cubic Normality & Canonical Angles (Eqs. 4.11–4.12)
§ 4.5.2 · INTERPLANAR SPACING dhkl & METRIC TENSOR

Metric Tensor \(g_{ij}=\boldsymbol{a}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{a}_j\) Unifies \(d_{hkl}\) Across All Seven Systems

\(\begin{gathered}\frac{1}{d_{hkl}^2}=\begin{pmatrix}h&k&l\end{pmatrix}\boldsymbol{g}^{-1}\begin{pmatrix}h\\k\\l\end{pmatrix}\\g_{ij}=\boldsymbol{a}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{a}_j\end{gathered}\)
  • Spacing & planar density: In primitive lattices \(V_{\text{cell}}=A_{\text{mesh}}\cdot d_{hkl}\)—low indices give larger \(d_{hkl}\), denser atomic planes, and easier slip or cleavage (centered bcc/fcc cells rank by true halved sub-spacings, making fcc \(\{111\}\) widest).
  • Origin of the hexagonal \(hk\) cross term: Basal \(\gamma=120^\circ\) produces off-diagonal \(g_{12}=a^2\cos 120^\circ=-\tfrac{1}{2}a^2\neq 0\), whose inverse \(\boldsymbol{g}^{-1}\) generates \(\tfrac{4}{3}(h^2+hk+k^2)/a^2\)!
SystemSpacing FormulaWorked Examples (Case 4.6)
Cubic
\(\boldsymbol{g}=a^2\boldsymbol{I}\)
\(d_{hkl}=\dfrac{a}{\sqrt{h^2+k^2+l^2}}\)sc: \(d_{100}=a\)
\(d_{110}=0.71a > d_{111}=0.58a\)
Tetrag. / Ortho.
Diagonal \(\boldsymbol{g}\)
\(\dfrac{1}{d_{hkl}^2}=\dfrac{h^2}{a^2}+\dfrac{k^2}{b^2}+\dfrac{l^2}{c^2}\)Tetragonal sets \(b=a\); stretching \(c\) expands \(d_{001}\) linearly
Hexagonal
\(g_{12}=-\tfrac{1}{2}a^2\)
\(\dfrac{1}{d_{hkl}^2}=\dfrac{4(h^2+hk+k^2)}{3a^2}+\dfrac{l^2}{c^2}\)\((0001)\): \(d=c\) (hcp: \(c/2\))
\((10\bar{1}0)\): \(d=\tfrac{\sqrt{3}}{2}a\)
Reciprocal-Space Bridge: \(1/d_{hkl}=|\boldsymbol{g}_{hkl}|\) is the Ch. 5 reciprocal-vector length, leading directly to Bragg’s law \(2d_{hkl}\sin\theta=\lambda\)!
Textbook § 4.5.2 · Interplanar Spacing & Metric Tensor \(\boldsymbol{g}\) (Eqs. 4.13–4.16, Case 4.6)
§ 4.5.3 · WEISS ZONE LAW

Independent of Lattice Constants: \(hu+kv+lw=0\) Governs Every Crystal Zone

\(\begin{gathered}hu+kv+lw=0\quad(\text{exact in all 7 systems!})\\\boldsymbol{u}=\boldsymbol{n}_1\times\boldsymbol{n}_2=\begin{vmatrix}\boldsymbol{e}_1&\boldsymbol{e}_2&\boldsymbol{e}_3\\h_1&k_1&l_1\\h_2&k_2&l_2\end{vmatrix}\end{gathered}\)
  • Metric-free duality: Plane normal \((hkl)\) is expressed in reciprocal basis vectors while direction \([uvw]\) uses direct basis vectors; biorthogonality \(\boldsymbol{b}_i\cdot\boldsymbol{a}_j=\delta_{ij}\) reduces their dot product identically to \(hu+kv+lw\)!
  • Case 4.7 (Cross-slip line): Crossing fcc slip planes \((1\bar{1}1)\times(111)=(-2,0,2)\Rightarrow[\bar{1}01]\)—a screw dislocation switches slip planes along this shared intersection!
  • TEM diffraction: With electron beam \(\boldsymbol{B}\parallel[uvw]\), planes obeying \(hu+kv+lw=0\) diffract together into the zero-order Laue zone (ZOLZ).
Textbook § 4.5.3 · Weiss Zone Law & Cross Products (Eqs. 4.17–4.18, Case 4.7)
LECTURE SUMMARY

Mastering the Quantitative Geometric Language of 3D Crystals

Sites (q,r,s)→Dirs [uvw] / [uvtw]→Planes (hkl) / (hkil)→Metric g & dhkl→Zone Law hu+kv+lw=0
ANSWER TO QUESTION 01

In 3-index hexagonal notation, \(120^\circ\)-equivalent close-packed basal axes read \([100],[110],[010]\), hiding 6-fold symmetry. Adding \(\boldsymbol{a}_3=-(\boldsymbol{a}_1+\boldsymbol{a}_2)\) enforces \(u+v+t=0\) (and \(h+k+i=0\) for planes), turning equivalent families into cyclic permutations of the first three digits (\(\langle 11\bar{2}0\rangle,\{10\bar{1}0\}\)).

ANSWER TO QUESTION 02

No longer perpendicular! Directions \([uvw]\) sum real-space basis vectors whereas plane normals \((hkl)\) sum reciprocal basis vectors. Only cubic \(\boldsymbol{g}=a^2\boldsymbol{I}\) aligns both bases; stretching to tetragonal \(c=1.5a\) tilts \([111]\) away from the \((111)\) normal by \(11.4^\circ\).

Next up: populate this geometric framework with real atoms and ions—bcc / fcc / hcp close packing, interstitial voids, and prototype ceramic compounds.

3D Crystallography II
QUICK QUIZ

Three Concept Checks: Click an Option or Launch a Class QR Poll

1. In a hexagonal crystal, converting 3-index direction \([110]\) and 3-index plane \((101)\) into Miller–Bravais 4-index form gives:

Directions use \(u=(2U-V)/3\) and \(v=(2V-U)/3\) to give \([11\bar{2}0]\); planes directly insert \(i=-(h+k)=-1\) to give \((10\bar{1}1)\). Never swap the two rules!

2. In a cubic crystal of lattice constant \(a\), what is the acute angle between adjacent octahedral slip planes \((111)\) and \((\bar{1}11)\)?

From \(\cos\theta=\frac{1(-1)+1(1)+1(1)}{\sqrt{3}\sqrt{3}}=\frac{1}{3}\), the acute dihedral angle is \(70.53^\circ\) (its supplement \(109.47^\circ\) is the tetrahedral \(\mathrm{sp^3}\) bond angle).

3. In any of the seven crystal systems, which crystal plane is guaranteed to contain direction \([11\bar{2}]\) (belonging to the \([11\bar{2}]\) zone)?

Weiss’s zone law \(hu+kv+lw=0\) holds across all seven crystal systems: for \((111)\), \(1(1)+1(1)+1(-2)=0\), so \([11\bar{2}]\) lies strictly inside \((111)\).

3D Crystallography II
FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · CHAPTER 4

Thank You

3 Embedded Models: Miller–Bravais 4-Index · Miller Index Lab · Cubic Planes & Spacing — mse3d.com