“Packing obstacles closer raises the dislocation bowing threshold Gb/L across every alloy—yet grain refinement alone strengthens a metal while simultaneously preserving its toughness.”Fundamentals of Materials Science · Ch. 12 · In Tribute to Schmid, Cottrell, Hall & Petch
PROLOGUE · FROM SINGLE DISLOCATIONS TO COLLECTIVE GLIDE, ENTANGLEMENT & STRENGTHENING LAWS
How Does Orientation Set Yielding, Why Do Lüders Bands Form, and Why Does Only Grain Refinement Toughen?
QUESTION 1 · CRYSTAL ORIENTATION VS. POLYCRYSTAL M̄ = 3.06
Pulling pure Cu single crystals from the same melt along different axes yields wildly different tensile yield stresses \(\sigma_y\)—what microscopic threshold stays invariant? And why must each polycrystal grain activate at least \(5\) independent slip systems, making it ~1.5× stronger than a soft single crystal?
QUESTION 2 · WORK HARDENING, YIELD DROP & 45° CREASES
More dislocations should ease slip, so why does cold bending harden iron wire? Why do automotive mild-steel sheets receive a \(1\%\text{–}3\%\) skin-pass temper roll before stamping, yet suffer \(45^\circ\) surface creases again after three months in storage?
QUESTION 3 · FOUR STRENGTHENING ROUTES & NANOSCALE LIMIT
Solid-solution, precipitation, and forest hardening all scale with \(\Delta\tau\propto Gb/L\): why does Hall–Petch obey \(d^{-1/2}\) instead of \(d^{-1}\), uniquely raising both strength and toughness—yet reverse and soften below \(10\text{–}20\text{ nm}\)?
This lecture connects the four pillars of macroscopic plasticity: true stress–strain & Schmid/Taylor laws \(\to\) work hardening & Considère necking \(\to\) Cottrell atmospheres & Lüders bands \(\to\) four strengthening mechanisms & inverse Hall–Petch.
Four StrengthenersShearing \(r^{1/2}\) vs. Orowan \(Gb/\lambda\) Hall–Petch \(d^{-1/2}\) & HSLA§ 12.9
Ch. 12 Part 3 of 4 · Covering § 12.6–§ 12.9 & HSLA Steel Case
01
PART I
True Stress–Strain, Schmid's Law & Taylor Factor
Separate true strain hardening from post-necking engineering load drop, project axial tension twice onto a slip system via Schmid's factor \(m\), and see how neighbor compatibility enforces 5 independent slip systems with Taylor factor \(\bar{M}=3.06\).
Engineering vs. true stress–strain, \(0.2\%\) offset yield, lattice rotation & Taylor factor \(\bar{M}=3.06\)05
Schmid's law \(\tau_{\mathrm{R}}=\sigma\cos\phi\cos\lambda\ge\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\), \(m_{\max}=0.5\) & slip activation model06
§ 12.6.1 & § 12.6.3 · TRUE VS. ENGINEERING STRESS–STRAIN, VON MISES 5 SYSTEMS & TAYLOR FACTOR M̄
True Stress Keeps Rising Past Necking; Neighbor Compatibility Enforces 5 Systems and \(\sigma_y = 3.06\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\)
True vs. Engineering Curves & \(\sigma_{0.2}\): Metals lacking a sharp yield drop define proof strength via the \(0.2\%\) plastic-offset line \(\sigma_{0.2}\); after necking (\(A\ll A_0\)), engineering stress \(s=\sigma_e=F/A_0\) falls while true stress \(\sigma=\sigma_t=F/A\) keeps hardening.
Answering Q1 Part 2 (Why \(\bar{M}=3.06\gt 2\)?): A soft single crystal (\(m=0.5\)) yields at \(\sigma_y=2\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\) on a single system, whereas each polycrystal grain constrained by surrounding neighbors must simultaneously activate \(\ge 5\) independent slip systems (many unfavorably oriented), lifting random fcc yield to \(\bar{M}\tau_{\mathrm{c}}=3.06\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\) (fcc has \(5\) independent systems for ductility; hcp basal slip has only \(2\), causing polycrystal brittleness).
§ 12.6.2 & § 12.6.4 · SCHMID'S LAW τR = σ cos φ cos λ ≥ τc, LATTICE ROTATION & SLIP ACTIVATION MODEL
Force Projection \(\cos\lambda\) Times Area Projection \(\cos\phi\) Peaks at \(m_{\max}=0.5\) for \(45^\circ\)
\(\begin{gathered}\tau_{\mathrm{R}}=\frac{F\cos\lambda}{A_0/\cos\phi}=\sigma\cos\phi\cos\lambda=m\sigma\ge\tau_{\mathrm{c}},\;\;\sigma_y=\frac{\tau_{\mathrm{c}}}{m}\;\;(\phi+\lambda\ge 90^\circ)\\ \phi=\lambda=45^\circ\Rightarrow m_{\max}=0.5\text{ (soft)}\;\mid\;\phi=90^\circ\text{ or }\lambda=90^\circ\Rightarrow m=0\text{ (locked)}\end{gathered}\)
Answering Q1 Part 1: Regardless of how \(\sigma_y\) varies with orientation, single-crystal Cu yields at an invariant critical resolved shear stress \(\tau_{\mathrm{c}}=m\sigma_y\approx 0.5\text{ MPa}\). At \(\phi=\lambda=45^\circ\)(\(m=0.5\)),\(\sigma_y=1.0\text{ MPa}\); at \(\phi=60^\circ,\;\lambda=38^\circ\)(\(m\approx 0.394\)),\(\sigma_y\) climbs to \(1.27\text{ MPa}\).
Multislip, Lattice Rotation & Overshoot: Pulling along \([001]\) co-activates \(8\) systems (\(m=0.408\)) for immediate hardening; single-slip axes rotate toward \(\langle 110\rangle\) under grip constraint and overshoot the \([001]\text{–}[111]\) symmetry boundary via latent hardening before conjugate slip.
Work Hardening, Considère Necking & Cottrell Atmospheres
Multiplying dislocations entangle into a dense forest that raises flow stress as \(\sqrt{\rho}\); necking strikes the instant hardening rate drops to true stress, while interstitial C/N clouds stage upper/lower yielding and \(45^\circ\) Lüders bands.
Three-stage single-crystal hardening, Hollomon law \(\sigma=K\varepsilon^n\) & Considère necking model08
Load Peaks When \(\mathrm{d}\sigma/\mathrm{d}\varepsilon = \sigma\): Uniform True Necking Strain Equals \(\varepsilon_u = n\)
\(\begin{gathered}\text{Stage I easy glide}\to\text{Stage II linear }\theta_{\mathrm{II}}\approx G/300\to\text{Stage III cross-slip recovery}\\ \mathrm{d}F=0\iff\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma}{\mathrm{d}\varepsilon}=\sigma\xrightarrow{\sigma=K\varepsilon^n}\varepsilon_u=n,\;\;e_u=\mathrm{e}^n-1\end{gathered}\)
Microscopic Origin of Stages I–III (Fig. 12.22): Stage I single slip glides long distances; Stage II multislip forest intersections & L–C locks set a universal slope \(\theta_{\mathrm{II}}\approx G/300\); Stage III screw cross-slip bypasses obstacles (low-SFE austenitic stainless steel suppresses cross-slip, prolonging Stage II with \(n\approx 0.48\)).
Considère Subtangent Rule: Necking starts precisely when subtangent \(\sigma/\theta=1\); higher \(n\) lets incipiently thinned spots self-harden and extends uniform elongation.
Answering Q2 Part 2 (Figs. 12.23 & 12.24): Trace interstitial C and N segregate into the dilated tensile zone beneath positive edge cores to relieve misfit strain and lock dislocations; axial stress must peak at the upper yield point \(\sigma_{\mathrm{uy}}\) to unpin (or multiply fresh mobile dislocations), then drops to the lower yield point \(\sigma_{\mathrm{ly}}\).
\(45^\circ\) Lüders Bands & Stretcher Strains: Localized yield bands at \(\sim 45^\circ\) (maximum shear) sweep from specimen shoulders across the entire gauge before uniform hardening starts, marring stamped auto body panels with unsightly stretcher-strain creases.
\(1\%\text{–}3\%\) Skin-Pass Rolling Erases Creases; \(170\,^\circ\mathrm{C}\) Paint Baking Re-Pins for Dent Resistance
\(\begin{gathered}\text{Skin-pass }(1\%\text{–}3\%)\implies\text{fresh mobile }\perp\text{ erase plateau}\;\;(\text{3-mo storage}\Rightarrow\text{strain aging})\\ v_{\mathrm{diff}}\approx v_{\mathrm{disl}}\;(200\text{–}300\,^\circ\mathrm{C}\text{ steel})\implies\text{repeated re-pinning}=\text{PLC serrations & blue brittleness}\end{gathered}\)
Two Remedies Against Creases: ① Light skin-pass temper rolling (\(1\%\text{–}3\%\)) injects unpinned mobile dislocations for smooth yielding, but sheets must be stamped promptly before room-temperature strain aging restores C/N clouds; ② Scavenging all free C/N with trace \(\mathrm{Ti/Nb}\) yields non-aging interstitial-free (IF) steel with strong \(\{111\}\) deep-drawing texture.
Bake Hardening (BH) vs. PLC Blue Brittleness: BH auto sheets retain trace solute C to stamp softly without creases, then re-pin during \(170\,^\circ\mathrm{C}\times 20\text{ min}\) paint baking (\(+\,40\text{–}60\text{ MPa}\) dent resistance). Conversely, working steel at \(200\text{–}300\,^\circ\mathrm{C}\) lets diffusing C/N repeatedly catch moving dislocations (Portevin–Le Chatelier dynamic strain aging), causing serrated flow and blue brittleness.
Four Strengthening Mechanisms & Inverse Hall–Petch
Solutes, precipitates, and forest dislocations all tighten bowing spacing \(L\); grain boundaries alone amplify stress via \(n\)-dislocation pile-ups to yield the \(d^{-1/2}\) law—powering tough HSLA steels until grain-boundary sliding takes over below \(10\text{–}20\text{ nm}\).
Solid-solution mismatch \(\Delta\tau\propto c^{1/2}\) & coherent shearing vs. Orowan looping 3D model13
Answering Q3 Part 1 (Origin of \(d^{-1/2}\)): Effective shear stress \(\tau^*=\tau-\tau_0\) enters twice—setting both pile-up count \(n\propto\tau^* d\) and force per dislocation—so finer grains hold fewer dislocations, weaken tip leverage, and demand higher applied stress \(\sigma_y=\sigma_0+k_y d^{-1/2}\).
Inverse Hall–Petch Below \(10\text{–}20\text{ nm}\): When \(d\lt d_c\approx 10\text{–}20\text{ nm}\), grains cannot fit pile-ups while boundary volume \(f_{\mathrm{gb}}\approx 3\delta/d\) hits \(\sim 30\%\), switching deformation to grain-boundary sliding softening (plus thermal coarsening & zero work hardening).
GBs block slip, shrinking pile-up count \(n\) & tip stress
\(\sigma_y=\sigma_0+k_y d^{-1/2}\) (\(d\gt d_c\))
Strength \(\uparrow\uparrow\) AND toughness rises (lowers DBTT)
HSLA pipeline steel, TMCP ultrafine steel
Answering Q3 Part 2 (“Strengthening” \(\ne\) “Toughening”): As-quenched martensite and heavy cold work raise \(\sigma_y\) sharply yet exhaust mobile dislocation capacity and shrink crack-tip plastic zones, inviting brittle fracture; grain refinement alone raises \(\sigma_y\) via shorter pile-ups while blunting grain-boundary stress concentration and deflecting cleavage cracks across high-angle boundaries to lower DBTT.
Textbook § 12.9 · Four Strengthening Mechanisms & Toughness
SUMMARY
Schmid Projection Sets Yielding, Considère Predicts Necking, and \(Gb/L\) + \(d^{-1/2}\) Govern Strengthening
Schmid m & M̄ = 3.06→Stages I–III & εu = n→Cottrell & 45° Lüders→Shear r¹/² vs. Gb/λ→Hall–Petch d⁻¹/²
ANSWERING QUESTIONS 1 & 2
Single crystals yield at invariant \(\tau_{\mathrm{R}}=m\sigma_y=\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\) (\(m_{\max}=0.5\) at \(45^\circ\)), while neighbor-constrained polycrystals require \(5\) independent slip systems (\(\sigma_y=3.06\tau_{\mathrm{c}}\)); forest intersections harden metals via \(\alpha Gb\sqrt{\rho}\), and C/N Cottrell unpinning stages mild-steel yield drops and \(45^\circ\) Lüders bands.
ANSWERING QUESTION 3
Solutes, Orowan particles, and forest dislocations all set \(Gb/L\) bowing thresholds, whereas grain boundaries leverage \(n\)-dislocation pile-ups (\(\tau_{\mathrm{tip}}=n\tau^*\propto(\tau^*)^2 d\)) to yield \(d^{-1/2}\)—uniquely raising both strength and toughness until \(d\lt 10\text{–}20\text{ nm}\) triggers grain-boundary sliding.
Three Quick Questions: Click an Option to Check or Launch a Live Class Poll
1. Single-crystal Cu is pulled at \(\phi=45^\circ,\;\lambda=45^\circ\) with \(\tau_{\mathrm{c}}=0.5\text{ MPa}\): what is \(\sigma_y\), and how many independent slip systems does von Mises polycrystal compatibility require?
2. Given \(G=80\text{ GPa},\;b=0.25\text{ nm}\) and non-shearable spacing \(\lambda=50\text{ nm}\), what is \(\tau_{\mathrm{Orowan}}\)? And for \(\sigma=K\varepsilon^{0.35}\), at what true strain \(\varepsilon_u\) does necking start?
3. For steel with \(\sigma_0=100\text{ MPa}\) and \(k_y=0.7\text{ MPa·m}^{1/2}\), what is \(\sigma_y\) at \(d=1\;\mu\text{m}\), and how are mild-steel stamping Lüders creases prevented?
At \(d=1\;\mu\text{m}\),\(d^{-1/2}=1000\text{ m}^{-1/2}\), so \(\sigma_y=100+0.7\times 1000=800\text{ MPa}\); prolonged storage triggers strain aging and restores creases.
Dislocations, Plasticity & Recrystallization III
FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · CHAPTER 12 (PART 3)