FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · CHAPTER 13 (CAPSTONE)

Fracture & Failure of Materials I

Griffith Energy Balance, Stress-Intensity Factor K & Safe Design
TEXTBOOK § 13.1 – § 13.2.1 · FRACTURE MECHANICS FOUNDATIONS · PART 1
“The general conclusion may be drawn that the weakness of isotropic solids, as ordinarily met with, is due to the presence of discontinuities, or flaws, as they may be more correctly called.”Alan A. Griffith (1893–1963) · Founder of Modern Fracture Mechanics
Liang Wumse3d.com · Smart Classroom
Center-cracked plate with Inglis relaxation ellipse \(a\times 2a\), crack-tip \(r^{-1/2}\) singular field & Irwin plastic lobes
ClickWheel→ NextP PenL LaserO OverviewT ThemeF Full
PROLOGUE · WHEN & HOW DO MATERIALS FAIL?

Fresh Glass Fibers Reach \(6\text{ GPa}\), Porcelain Shatters While Iron Dents — What Really Governs Strength?

QUESTION 01 · SIZE PARADOX

Why Are Finer Glass Fibers Stronger?

Interatomic bonds predict cohesive strength \(\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx E/10\) (tens of GPa). Fresh micron glass fibers reach \(6\text{ GPa}\), yet aged fibers or \(1\text{ mm}\) rods drop to \(0.17\text{ GPa}\) — why isn't strength a fixed constant?

QUESTION 02 · BOWL VS. SKILLET

Why Are Metals \(100\times\) Tougher Than Ceramics?

Plugging steel's \(E\), surface energy \(\gamma\), and crack length into Griffith's pure brittle formula underpredicts fracture stress by \(10\text{–}100\times\). What crack-tip energy sink pushes metal \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) past \(100\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\)?

QUESTION 03 · SHIP SPLIT IN HARBOR

Why Did Hulls Snap Far Below Yield?

In 1943, the all-welded tanker S.S. Schenectady split in two in calm harbor water at nominal stress well below \(\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\). How do engineers guarantee safe service even when real structures contain flaws?

Our thread: Griffith Energy Balance \(\to\) Irwin Plastic Work & \(G\) \(\to\) Williams \(K\)-Field & \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) \(\to\) Crack-Tip Plastic Zone \(\to\) Dual Criteria & Leak-Before-Break.

Ch. 13 Intro & § 13.1 · Ideal Bonds to Fracture Mechanics
LECTURE STRUCTURE · § 13.1 – § 13.2.1

From Surface Cost \(2\gamma\) vs. Strain-Energy Release to the Universal \(K_{\mathrm{I}}\le K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) Shield

  1. Cohesive StrengthOrowan half-sine \(\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx\sqrt{E\gamma/a_0}\)
    Griffith glass-fiber size effect
    § 13.1.1
  2. Griffith EquationInglis ellipse \(U_{\mathrm{el}}\propto -a^2\)
    \(\partial U/\partial a=0\Rightarrow\sigma_f\propto a^{-1/2}\)
    § 13.1.2 · Model
  3. Plastic Work & \(G\)\(2\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}=2\gamma+\gamma_p\) (\(\gamma_p\gg 2\gamma\))
    Energy release rate \(G\le R\)
    § 13.1.3
  4. \(K\)-Field & Plastic Zone\(r^{-1/2}\) singularity · \(K_{\mathrm{I}}=Y\sigma\sqrt{\pi a}\)
    Plane-strain \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) & \(r_p\) lobes
    § 13.1.4–13.2.1 · Model
  5. Safe Design & LBBLiberty Ship fracture audit · \(a_c\)
    Vessel wall dual constraints
    § 13.1.5 · 2 Cases
§ 13.1 – § 13.2.1 · Fracture Mechanics & Plastic Zone
01
PART I · § 13.1.1 – § 13.1.3

Cohesive Strength, Griffith Energy Balance & Irwin Plastic Work

Turning flaws from unquantified workshop blemishes into rigorous thermodynamic objects, and resolving the hundredfold toughness gap between glass and steel via \(2\gamma\) vs. \(\gamma_p\).
  1. Orowan cohesive estimate \(\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx\sqrt{E\gamma/a_0}\approx E/10\) & glass-fiber size paradox05
  2. Griffith energy ledger: Inglis relaxation ellipse, surface cost \(4\gamma aB\) & \(\sigma_f\propto a^{-1/2}\)06
  3. Interactive 2D Model (M12·01): Griffith energy landscape & soda-lime glass benchmark07
  4. Irwin–Orowan plastic work \(\gamma_p\gg 2\gamma\), energy release rate \(G\) & \(G\le R\) criterion08
§ 13.1.1 · OROWAN THEORETICAL COHESIVE STRENGTH & GRIFFITH'S FIBER EXPERIMENTS

Snapping an Entire Atomic Plane Requires \(\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx\sqrt{E\gamma/a_0}\approx E/10\) — \(10\text{–}100\times\) Above Bulk Tests

\(\begin{gathered}\sigma(x)=\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\sin\!\left(\frac{\pi x}{\lambda}\right),\;\;\int_0^{\lambda}\sigma\,\mathrm{d}x=\frac{2\lambda}{\pi}\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx 2\gamma,\;\;\left.\frac{\mathrm{d}\sigma}{\mathrm{d}x}\right|_0=\frac{\pi\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}}{\lambda}\approx\frac{E}{a_0}\\ \Longrightarrow\;\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx\sqrt{\frac{E\gamma}{a_0}}\;\;(\text{DFT }\approx E/10;\text{ steel }\sim 20\text{ GPa}\gg\text{bulk }0.4\text{–}1.5\text{ GPa})\end{gathered}\)
  • Ch. 2 & Ch. 9 Link: Modulus \(E\) and surface energy \(\gamma\) stem from the same interatomic well — narrower wells snap earlier, lowering \(\gamma/(Ea_0)\) and \(\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}/E\).
  • Answer to Q1 (Griffith 1920): Fresh flaw-free glass fibers hit \(6\text{ GPa}\); after brief exposure, \(\varnothing 3.5\;\mu\text{m}\) fibers hold \(3.4\text{ GPa}\) while \(\varnothing 1\text{ mm}\) rods fall to \(0.17\text{ GPa}\) — thicker specimens harbor larger flaws, so real strength is flaw-controlled.
Atomic separation \(x/\lambda\): x = 0.50 λ
§ 13.1.1 · Orowan Cohesive Strength (Eqs. 13.1–13.4)
§ 13.1.2 · INGLIS RELAXATION ELLIPSE, SURFACE ENERGY & INSTABILITY CRITERION \(\partial U/\partial a\le 0\)

Crack Growth Releases Strain Energy \(\propto -a^2\) vs. Surface Cost \(\propto +a\): Past the Peak, Catastrophe

Four-Term Potential & Inglis Ellipse (Fig. 13.1)

\(\begin{gathered}U=(-W)+U_{\mathrm{el}}+U_{\mathrm{s}}+U_{\mathrm{kin}},\quad U_{\mathrm{el}}(a)=-\frac{\pi\sigma^2 a^2 B}{E'},\;\;U_{\mathrm{s}}(a)=4\gamma aB\\ E'=\begin{cases}E,&\text{plane stress (thin sheet)}\\ E/(1-\nu^2),&\text{plane strain (thick plate)}\end{cases}\end{gathered}\)
  • Inglis Relaxation Ledger: Opening a through-crack of length \(2a\) unloads an elliptical zone of semi-axes \(a\times 2a\) (area \(2\pi a^2\)), releasing \(\frac{\sigma^2}{2E'}\cdot 2\pi a^2 B\); advancing both tips by \(\mathrm{d}a\) creates four new faces of area \(4B\,\mathrm{d}a\).
  • Grain-Boundary Link (Ch. 9): Intergranular fracture costs \(2\gamma_{\mathrm{s}}-\gamma_{\mathrm{gb}}\). Clean boundaries (\(\gamma_{\mathrm{gb}}\approx\gamma_{\mathrm{s}}/3\)) save only \(1/6\), whereas impurity segregation slashes cohesion and triggers intergranular embrittlement.

Griffith Equation & Engineering Consequences (Eq. 13.9)

\(\frac{\partial U}{\partial a}=-\frac{2\pi\sigma^2 aB}{E'}+4\gamma B=0\implies\sigma_f=\sqrt{\frac{2E'\gamma}{\pi a}}\propto a^{-1/2}\)
  • ① Strength Is Not a Material Constant: Jointly set by intrinsic \((E',\gamma)\) and extrinsic half-flaw size \(a\).
  • ② Inverse Square-Root Law: Shrinking max flaw size to \(1/4\) raises \(\sigma_f\) by only \(2\times\) — eliminating flaws beats polishing them shorter.
  • ③ Runaway Instability: Once \(a\gt a_c\), longer cracks need lower \(\sigma_f\); under dead load, excess energy feeds \(U_{\mathrm{kin}}\) at hundreds of m/s.
§ 13.1.2 · Griffith Energy Balance (Eqs. 13.5–13.9)
§ 13.1.2 · ENERGY HILLTOP \(a_c\) & COHESIVE CAP INTERACTIVE SANDBOX

Drag Half-Crack \(a\): Stable Uphill Left of \(a_c\), Runaway Fracture Past the Hilltop \(a_c\)

\(\begin{gathered}\text{Soda-Lime Glass Benchmark:}\\ E=70\text{ GPa},\;\gamma=0.5\text{ J/m}^2,\;2a=10\;\mu\text{m}\;(a=5\;\mu\text{m})\\ \sigma_f=\sqrt{\frac{2\times 70\times 10^9\times 0.5}{\pi\times 5\times 10^{-6}}}\approx 66.8\text{ MPa}\end{gathered}\)
  • Preset Verification: Select Soda-Lime Glass to verify \(\sigma_f\approx 66.8\text{ MPa}\). Toggle With \(\gamma_p\) to compare measured \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}=0.75\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\) — \(G_c\approx 8\text{ J/m}^2\approx 8\times 2\gamma\) from crack-tip inelastic loss.
  • Flaw-Free Fiber Limit: Switch to Fresh Glass Fiber — as \(a\to a_0\), the Griffith hyperbola plateaus at Orowan's cohesive cap \(\sigma_{\mathrm{th}}\approx E/10\).
§ 13.1.2 · Griffith Potential Peak & Cohesive Cap
§ 13.1.3 · GEORGE IRWIN, PLASTIC DISSIPATION \(\gamma_p\) & GENERAL ENERGY CRITERION \(G\le R\)

Crack-Tip Plasticity Absorbs Four Orders of Magnitude More Energy: \(\gamma_p\sim 10^4\text{ J/m}^2\gg 2\gamma\)

Answer to Q2: Why Pure \(2\gamma\) Fails for Metals

\(R=2\gamma_{\mathrm{eff}}=2\gamma+\gamma_p\;\;(\text{steels: }\gamma_p\sim 10^4\text{ J/m}^2\approx 10^4\times\gamma!)\)
  • Irwin & Orowan Breakthrough (1948): In glass and ceramics, immobile dislocations leave \(R\approx 2\gamma\sim 1\text{–}10\text{ J/m}^2\), so bowls shatter. In metals, massive dislocation slip ahead of the crack tip dissipates \(\gamma_p\), amplifying fracture resistance ten-thousandfold.
  • George R. Irwin (NRL): Extended Griffith's brittle balance to quasi-brittle structural metals, founding Linear Elastic Fracture Mechanics (LEFM).

Energy Release Rate \(G\) & Criterion (Eqs. 13.11–13.13)

\(\begin{gathered}G\equiv -\frac{\partial\Pi}{\partial A}\;\;(\Pi=U_{\mathrm{el}}-W;\text{ center }\mathrm{d}A=2B\,\mathrm{d}a,\text{ edge }\mathrm{d}A=B\,\mathrm{d}a)\\ G=\frac{\pi\sigma^2 a}{E'}\;\left\{\begin{array}{l}\lt R\;\text{stable (no growth)}\\ =R=G_c\;\text{critical (onset)}\\ \gt R\;\text{unstable fracture}\end{array}\right.\end{gathered}\)
  • Driving Force vs. Resistance Split: Left-hand \(G\;(\text{J/m}^2)\) is mechanical energy supplied per unit crack area by load and geometry; right-hand \(R=G_c\) is a measurable material property.
§ 13.1.3 · Plastic Work & Critical Energy Release Rate
02
PART II · § 13.1.4 – § 13.2.1

Crack-Tip Singular Field, \(K\)-Factor, Three Modes & Plastic Zone

Capturing the entire \(r^{-1/2}\) singular stress field with a single scalar \(K_{\mathrm{I}}=Y\sigma\sqrt{\pi a}\), then seeing how real yielding blunts infinity into a twin-lobed plastic zone \(r_p\).
  1. Inglis notch limit, Williams \(r^{-1/2}\) asymptotic field, \(K_{\mathrm{I}}=Y\sigma\sqrt{\pi a}\) & Modes I/II/III10
  2. Plane-strain fracture toughness \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\), ASTM small-scale yielding size rule & \(G=K^2/E'\)11
  3. Crack-tip plastic zone: first-order \(r_y\), Irwin redistribution \(r_p=2r_y\) & \(\gamma_p\sim K^2/(\pi E)\)12
  4. Interactive 2D Model (M12·03): \(K\)-dominance ring, twin-lobe \(r_p\) & weld flaw benchmarks13
§ 13.1.4 · WILLIAMS \(r^{-1/2}\) EXPANSION, STRESS-INTENSITY FACTOR \(K_{\mathrm{I}}=Y\sigma\sqrt{\pi a}\) & MODES I–III

As Tip Radius \(\rho\to 0\) Stress Diverges — Irwin's Scalar Amplitude \(K\) Quantifies Crack Severity

\(\begin{gathered}k_t=1+2\sqrt{a/\rho}\xrightarrow{\rho\to 0}\infty,\quad\sigma_{ij}(r,\theta)=\frac{K_{\mathrm{I}}}{\sqrt{2\pi r}}f_{ij}(\theta)+\cdots\\ K_{\mathrm{I}}\equiv\lim_{r\to 0,\theta=0}\sqrt{2\pi r}\,\sigma_{yy}\implies K_{\mathrm{I}}=Y\sigma\sqrt{\pi a}\;\;(\text{MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}})\end{gathered}\)
  • \(K\)-Dominance Radius (Fig. 13.2b): Against exact center-crack \(\sigma_{yy}=\sigma(a+r)/\sqrt{r(2a+r)}\), the singular term is within \(4\%\) at \(r=a/20\) but drops below \(2/3\) of exact at \(r=a\).
  • Three Fundamental Modes (Fig. 13.3): Mode I (opening — most common & dangerous), Mode II (in-plane sliding), and Mode III (anti-plane tearing).
§ 13.1.4 · Williams Field, K-Factor & Modes I–III
§ 13.1.5 · PLANE-STRAIN FRACTURE TOUGHNESS \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\), ASTM SIZE RULE & \(G=K^2/E'\) EQUIVALENCE

Thin Sheets Overestimate Toughness — Thick-Plate Plane Strain Locks Triaxial Tension at True Lower-Bound \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\)

Representative Engineering MaterialToughness \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\;(\text{MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}})\)Micro-Dissipation & Design Role
Nuclear Vessel Steel A533B (RT)\(\sim 150\) (upper shelf \(\sim 200\))Large plastic zone & microvoid coalescence; premier Leak-Before-Break steel
Ultra-High-Strength Steel (\(\sigma_{\mathrm{UTS}}\gt 2\text{ GPa}\))\(\sim 30\)Heavily pinned dislocations, tiny \(r_p\); highly sensitive to mm-scale flaws
Aerospace Al Alloy 2024-T3\(\approx 34\)Fuselage skin alloy; paired with damage-tolerant NDE inspection schedules
Alumina \(\mathrm{Al_2O_3}\) / Soda-Lime Glass\(\approx 4\) / \(\approx 0.75\)Virtually zero dislocation relaxation; designed via Weibull flaw statistics

Plane-Strain Small-Scale Yielding Rule (Eq. 13.18)

\(B,\;a,\;(W-a)\ge 2.5\!\left(\frac{K_{\mathrm{IC}}}{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}\right)^2\)

Thick plates suppress through-thickness contraction, inducing triaxial tension to yield the thickness-independent minimum \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\); ultra-tough steels use elastic–plastic \(J\)-integral or CTOD.

Exact \(G\text{–}K\) Crack-Closure Equivalence (Eq. 13.19)

\(G=\frac{K^2}{E'}=\begin{cases}K^2/E,&\text{plane stress}\\ (1-\nu^2)K^2/E,&\text{plane strain}\end{cases}\)

Integrating singular stress \(\propto r^{-1/2}\) against opening displacement \(\propto r^{1/2}\) yields finite closure work: \(G_c=K_{\mathrm{IC}}^2/E'=2\gamma+\gamma_p\).

§ 13.1.5 · KIC Spectrum, ASTM Rule & G = K²/E′
§ 13.2.1 · IRWIN REDISTRIBUTION \(r_p=2r_y\), PLANE-STRESS VS. PLANE-STRAIN LOBES & PLASTIC WORK

Truncating Stress Above \(\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\) Doubles the Plastic Zone to \(r_p=2r_y\) and Dissipates \(K^2/(\pi E)\)

First-Order \(r_y\) to Irwin Redistribution \(r_p=2r_y\) (Fig. 13.5)

\(\begin{gathered}r_y=\frac{1}{2\pi}\!\left(\frac{K_{\mathrm{I}}}{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}\right)^2\xrightarrow{\int_0^{r_y}\sigma_{yy}\mathrm{d}r=2\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}r_y}r_p=2r_y\\ r_p\approx\begin{cases}\dfrac{1}{\pi}\!\left(\dfrac{K_{\mathrm{I}}}{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}\right)^2,&\text{plane stress (broad peanut zone)}\\ \dfrac{1}{3\pi}\!\left(\dfrac{K_{\mathrm{I}}}{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}\right)^2,&\text{plane strain (triaxial tension }\to 1/3\text{ dog-bone)}\end{cases}\end{gathered}\)
  • Geometric Meaning of \(2.5(K_{\mathrm{IC}}/\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}})^2\): Since \(2.5\approx 8\times\frac{1}{\pi}\approx 24\times\frac{1}{3\pi}\), the ASTM rule enforces \(B,a\gg r_p\) so the elastic \(K\)-field still surrounds the plastic zone.

Self-Consistent Plastic-Work Scaling (Eq. 13.24)

\(\gamma_p\sim\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\,\varepsilon_p\,r_p\sim\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\cdot\frac{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}{E}\cdot\frac{1}{\pi}\!\left(\frac{K}{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}\right)^2=\frac{K^2}{\pi E}\)
  • Microscopic Closure: Unit crack advance sweeps a plastic wake of thickness \(\sim r_p\) at strain \(\varepsilon_p\sim\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}/E\). For steel with \(K\sim 100\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\) and \(E=200\text{ GPa}\), \(\gamma_p\sim 1.6\times 10^4\text{ J/m}^2\), matching \(G_c=K^2/E'\).
  • Strength–Toughness Trade-Off: Raising \(\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\) alone shrinks \(r_p\propto\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}^{-2}\), starving plastic dissipation and embrittling ultra-strong alloys.
§ 13.2.1 · Plastic Zone rp & Plastic Work Scaling
§ 13.1.4 & § 13.2.1 · SINGLE-PARAMETER \(K\)-SIMILITUDE & PLASTIC-ZONE SANDBOX

Toggle “Lock \(K_{\mathrm{I}}\)” While Sweeping \(\sigma\) and \(a\): Remote Loads Shift, Yet the Crack-Tip Field Stays Identical

\(\begin{gathered}\text{Weld Flaw Benchmark: }a=5\text{ mm},\;Y=1.12,\;\sigma=200\text{ MPa}\\ K_{\mathrm{I}}=1.12\times 200\sqrt{\pi\times 0.005}\approx 28.1\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\lt 80\;(\text{safe})\\ \text{Low-Tough Steel (}K_{\mathrm{IC}}=40\text{): }a_c=\frac{1}{\pi}\!\left(\frac{40}{1.12\times 200}\right)^2\approx 10.1\text{ mm}\end{gathered}\)
  • Exploration ①: Switch Plane Stress / Plane Strain to watch the plastic zone contract \(3\times\) ahead of the tip from a broad peanut into a pinched twin-lobe dog-bone.
  • Exploration ②: Click Low-Tough Steel (B11) — halving \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) cuts critical flaw size \(a_c\) to \(1/4\) (\(10.1\text{ mm}\)), demanding tighter NDE flaw detection.
§ 13.1.4 & § 13.2.1 · K-Dominance & Irwin Plastic Zone
03
PART III · § 13.1.5 & ENGINEERING CASES 13.1–13.2

Dual-Criteria Safe Design, Liberty Ships & Leak-Before-Break

Yield design prevents global plastic collapse while the \(K_{\mathrm{I}}\le K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) criterion prevents unstable fracture — two coupled safeguards protecting ships, reactors, and pressure vessels.
  1. Case 13.1: WWII Liberty Ships & S.S. Schenectady cold brittle fracture — four-factor autopsy & numbers15
  2. Case 13.2: Yield + Fracture dual criteria (FAD), Leak-Before-Break (LBB) & vessel wall-thickness lab16
§ 13.1.4 CASE 13.1 · 2,700 LIBERTY SHIPS & THE HARBOR FRACTURE OF S.S. SCHENECTADY

Nominal Stress Was Only \(167\text{ MPa}\lt\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\) (\(250\text{ MPa}\)): Yield Design Passed, \(K\)-Criterion Failed

Four Lethal Factors Converging

  • ① All-Welded Hulls vs. Rivets: Riveted lap seams naturally arrested running cracks; monolithic welded hulls gave a crack an unbroken elastic highway.
  • ② Wartime Weld Defects: Slag inclusions, lack of fusion, and arc-strike cracks routinely left initial flaws of \(a\sim 5\text{–}30\text{ mm}\).
  • ③ Sub-DBTT Cold Seas: Coarse-grained high-P/S plate at \(-5\,^\circ\mathrm{C}\) dropped onto the lower shelf, slashing \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) from \(\sim 100\) to \(30\text{–}40\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\).
  • ④ Square Hatch Corners + Residual Stress: Sharp corners (\(k_t\gt 3\)) plus weld residual tension near \(\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\) loaded the hull even in calm water.

Quantitative Autopsy & Modern Grade-E Steel Cure

\(\begin{gathered}\text{Liberty Hull (}K_{\mathrm{IC}}=40,\;a=15\text{ mm},\;Y=1.1\text{):}\\ \sigma_f=\frac{40}{1.1\sqrt{\pi\times 0.015}}\approx 167\text{ MPa}\lt\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\;(250\text{ MPa})\\ \text{If }a=60\text{ mm (unfused seam)}\implies\sigma_f\approx 84\text{ MPa}\approx\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}/3!\\ \text{Modern Grade-E Steel (}K_{\mathrm{IC}}=100\text{): }a_c=\frac{1}{\pi}\!\left(\frac{100}{1.1\times 167}\right)^2\approx 94\text{ mm}\;(\uparrow 6.25\times!)\end{gathered}\)

Three Engineering Legacies: ① Mandatory low-temp Charpy Grade D/E steels; ② Rounded hatch corners to cut \(k_t\); ③ Tough crack-arrester strakes.

§ 13.1.4 Case 13.1 · Liberty Ship Fracture Autopsy
§ 13.1.5 CASE 13.2 · DUAL DESIGN CRITERIA (FAD), LEAK-BEFORE-BREAK (LBB) & VESSEL WALL THICKNESS

Balanced Steel Yields Safely Before Fracture — Blindly Swapping to \(1500\text{ MPa}\) Brittle Steel Forces \(t\ge 42\text{ mm}\)

\(\begin{gathered}\text{Dual Criteria: }\sigma\le\frac{\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}}{n_s}\;\;\text{and}\;\;K_{\mathrm{I}}=Y\sigma\sqrt{\pi a_{\mathrm{det}}}\le\frac{K_{\mathrm{IC}}}{n_k},\;\;a_c=\frac{1}{\pi}\!\left(\frac{K_{\mathrm{IC}}}{Y\sigma}\right)^2\\ \text{Leak-Before-Break (through-wall }a=t\text{ stable): }\;t\lt\frac{1}{\pi}\!\left(\frac{K_{\mathrm{IC}}}{\sigma}\right)^2\end{gathered}\)
  • Answer to Q3 (Damage-Tolerant Design): Size wall thickness \(t\) against NDE detection limit \(a_{\mathrm{det}}\). For Case 13.2 (\(p=15\text{ MPa},\) \(D=800\text{ mm},\) \(a_{\mathrm{det}}=5\text{ mm}\)): tough \(600\text{ MPa}\) steel at \(t=20\text{ mm}\) prevents yield and satisfies LBB (\(t\lt 22.6\text{ mm}\)); brittle \(1500\text{ MPa}\) steel (\(K_{\mathrm{IC}}=30\)) forces \(t\ge 42.1\text{ mm}\) and bursts without warning.
§ 13.1.5 Case 13.2 · Dual Criteria & Leak-Before-Break
SUMMARY

Flaws Pull Strength Down from \(E/10\), Plastic Work \(\gamma_p\) Grants Toughness, and \(K_{\mathrm{I}}\le K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) Guards Service

Cohesive √(Eγ/a₀)→Griffith σf ∝ a⁻¹/²→Irwin R = 2γ + γp→K-Field KI = Yσ√(πa)→Dual Criteria & LBB
ANSWERING QUESTIONS 1 & 2

Real strength is governed by the worst flaw, so micron glass fibers without large defects approach \(E/10\). In metals, the crack-tip plastic zone \(r_p\propto(K/\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}})^2\) dissipates \(\gamma_p\sim 10^4\text{ J/m}^2\gg 2\gamma\), making an iron skillet nearly \(100\times\) tougher in \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) than porcelain.

ANSWERING QUESTION 3

At \(-5\,^\circ\mathrm{C}\), Liberty Ship steel fell to \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\approx 40\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\), letting a \(15\text{ mm}\) weld flaw hit \(K_{\mathrm{I}}=K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) at \(167\text{ MPa}\lt\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}}\). Modern design enforces coupled yield + \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) criteria and Leak-Before-Break \(t\lt\frac{1}{\pi}(K_{\mathrm{IC}}/\sigma)^2\).

Next Lecture: Fracture & Failure of Materials II — Cottrell cleavage & river patterns, microvoid dimples, Titanic DBTT & Aloha Flight 243 Paris fatigue life.

Fracture & Failure of Materials I
CONCEPT QUIZ

Three Quick Questions: Click an Option to Check or Launch a Live Class Poll

1. A brittle glass plate holds a center through-crack of length \(2a\). If precision polishing shrinks the maximum crack length to \(1/4\) of its original value, Griffith's equation predicts fracture stress \(\sigma_f\) becomes:

From Griffith's law \(\sigma_f\propto a^{-1/2}\), reducing \(a\to a/4\) raises \(\sigma_f\) by \((1/4)^{-1/2}=2\times\).

2. Why must standard fracture toughness \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\) be measured on thick specimens satisfying \(B,a,(W-a)\ge 2.5(K_{\mathrm{IC}}/\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}})^2\)?

Thick plates constrain thickness contraction, building triaxial tension that shrinks \(r_p=\frac{1}{3\pi}(K/\sigma_{\mathrm{ys}})^2\) to yield the thickness-independent minimum \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}\).

3. A vessel weld holds an \(a=5\text{ mm}\) surface flaw (\(Y=1.12\)) under \(\sigma=200\text{ MPa}\). Find \(K_{\mathrm{I}}\), and find critical flaw size \(a_c\) if swapped to steel with \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}=40\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\):

\(K_{\mathrm{I}}=1.12\times 200\sqrt{0.005\pi}\approx 28.1\text{ MPa}\sqrt{\text{m}}\); with \(K_{\mathrm{IC}}=40\), \(a_c=\frac{1}{\pi}[40/(1.12\times 200)]^2\approx 10.1\text{ mm}\).

Fracture & Failure of Materials I
FUNDAMENTALS OF MATERIALS SCIENCE · CHAPTER 13 (PART 1)

Thank You

2 Embedded Interactive 2D Models: Griffith Energy Balance (M12·01) · Crack-Tip K Field & Plastic Zone (M12·03) — mse3d.com